Cortisol (your body's main stress hormone) is meant to rise in short bursts and then settle back down. When stress keeps it high for too long, it can take a real toll on your health. Mayo Clinic links too much exposure to cortisol and other stress hormones with anxiety, poor sleep, headaches, weight gain, trouble focusing, and a higher risk of high blood pressure and heart disease.¹

Cortisol supplements promise to help. So which one actually delivers?

We compared four popular options for women: Alori Cortisol, Pink Stork Cortisol Complex, Integrative Therapeutics Cortisol Manager, and Midi Daily Cortisol Support. We judged each on ingredients and formulation, research and third-party testing, daily use and convenience, and price and value. One came out as the clear winner. Read on to find out which.

What To Look For In Cortisol Supplements

We judged every supplement on the same four things.

• Ingredients and dose transparency: The best formulas list the exact amount of every ingredient, so you know what you're taking. A proprietary blend (a group of ingredients with one combined weight) hides how much of each you get.
• Supporting research: The strongest evidence comes from studies that tested the same ingredient at the same daily dose against a placebo and measured cortisol directly.
• Daily use and tolerability: A good routine is simple to keep up every day, fits the time of day you want to take it, and comes with clear guidance.
• Price and value: What counts is the daily cost of the recommended amount.

Let's see how Alori, Pink Stork, Integrative Therapeutics, and Midi compare.

Cortisol Supplements Compared

Ingredients & Formulation: Alori Wins with Every Dose Listed and No Blends

With stress supplements, the dose is everything. An herb at a fraction of the amount used in research may do very little, and you can only judge that if the label tells you how much is inside. We looked at what each formula contains and how clearly it lists every amount.

🥇 The winner: Alori Cortisol. Every amount is on the label with no blends. It's also the only formula here without ashwagandha, built instead around tongkat ali and rhodiola, so it gives you a different option if ashwagandha hasn't worked for you. Each two-capsule serving has 200 mg of tongkat ali for a healthier stress response and 500 mg of rhodiola to help your body adapt to stress. It adds 500 mg of shilajit for steady energy without stimulants, 10 mg of pregnenolone (a building block your body uses to make cortisol and other hormones), and 15 mg of zinc for normal hormone and immune function. A small 5 mg dose of black pepper extract helps your body absorb it all.²

🥈 Runner-up: Pink Stork Cortisol Complex. Each two-capsule serving has 300 mg of organic ashwagandha, an herb known for its calming effect that Pink Stork says supports healthy cortisol levels and lower stress. It adds 75 mg of saffron to support mood, 800 IU of vitamin D, 100 mg of blueberry, and 100 mg of milk thistle, which Pink Stork includes to help your body clear excess cortisol. Its DHA, chamomile, and B vitamins have no amounts, and the product page lists saffron and milk thistle in some sections but not in its main ingredient list.³

🥉 Third: Integrative Therapeutics Cortisol Manager. Two tablets give you 100 mg of phosphatidylserine (a fat-like compound found in your brain cells), plus two blends. A 500 mg blend combines Sensoril ashwagandha, a branded extract that lowered cortisol in a study of stressed adults, with L-theanine (a calming compound found in tea). A 450 mg blend combines magnolia bark with epimedium (a plant extract), which the brand includes to help bring cortisol down. Because of the blends, you can't tell how much ashwagandha you're getting.⁴

❌ Fourth: Midi Daily Cortisol Support. Midi combines KSM-66 ashwagandha (another branded extract), L-theanine, and magnesium glycinate, which it says work together to support a balanced stress response, clearer thinking, and more restful sleep. It also includes phosphatidylserine and magnolia bark, but its product page doesn't list how much of any of them is in each serving.⁵

Research & Third-Party Testing: Alori Wins with the Only Exact Dose Match to a Cortisol Study

🥇 The winner: Alori Cortisol. Alori's 200 mg of tongkat ali is the same daily amount used in a study of 63 moderately stressed adults. After four weeks, the group taking tongkat ali had 16% lower cortisol in their saliva than the placebo group, along with less tension and anger.⁶ Alori also cites a 28-day rhodiola study on stress-related fatigue that used 576 mg a day, close to its own 500 mg.⁷ The formula is third-party tested and made in a cGMP facility (one that follows the FDA's manufacturing quality rules).²

🥈 Runner-up: Integrative Therapeutics Cortisol Manager. Integrative Therapeutics names its ashwagandha extract Sensoril and cites a placebo-controlled study showing it lowered cortisol in people under high stress. Because the ashwagandha sits inside a blend, though, you can't tell whether your dose matches the study's and if it will be enough to feel the benefits.⁴ For testing, it runs its own accredited lab, checks every raw ingredient lot for purity and potency, and holds an outside certification for its manufacturing practices.⁸

🥉 Third: Pink Stork Cortisol Complex. Pink Stork cites an ashwagandha study that found 27.9% lower cortisol than placebo over 60 days. That study used 300 mg twice a day, whereas Pink Stork gives you 300 mg total per day, meaning the dose is half the effectively recorded dosage. Independent reviews support ashwagandha in general,⁹ but not at this lower dose.. Pink Stork says independent labs check every lot for potency, label accuracy, heavy metals, and microbes before it ships.³

❌ Fourth: Midi Daily Cortisol Support. Midi uses KSM-66, one of the most studied ashwagandha extracts. In a well-known 60-day study of 64 stressed adults, 600 mg/day of KSM-66 reduced cortisol by 27.9% compared with placebo.¹⁰,¹¹ Midi doesn't list how much KSM-66 is in each serving, so there's no way to compare. Midi claims the product is third-party tested, but further information is not disclosed.⁵

Daily Use & Convenience: Midi, Alori, and Pink Stork Tie with Simple Once-a-Day Routines

These supplements are meant to be taken every day for weeks before you judge the results, so the routine has to be easy to keep up. We compared how much you take and when.

🥇 Tied winner: Midi Daily Cortisol Support. Take two capsules a day, with or without food. Midi suggests the evening, though it says some women split the dose between morning and night.⁵

🥇 Tied winner: Alori Cortisol. Take two capsules once a day. Alori suggests the morning, so the steady energy it aims for carries you through the day.²,¹²

🥇 Tied winner: Pink Stork Cortisol Complex. Take two capsules a day. The page doesn't give a set time, though some users prefer the morning.³

🥈 Runner-up: Integrative Therapeutics Cortisol Manager. Take one tablet at bedtime, increasing to two during periods of high stress. That makes it a nighttime-only routine with a dose you have to adjust.⁴

Price & Value: Integrative Therapeutics Wins with the Lowest Daily Cost

You'll likely take a cortisol supplement for at least a few months, so small differences in daily cost add up. We compared one-time prices at each brand's recommended daily amount.

🥇 The winner: Integrative Therapeutics Cortisol Manager. A 30-tablet bottle costs $26.75. At the standard one tablet a night, that's about $0.89 per day, and the bottle lasts a full month. On high-stress days when you take two, it rises to about $1.78 per day, and the bottle lasts 15 days. It has the lowest starting daily cost of the four.⁴,¹³

🥈 Runner-up: Pink Stork Cortisol Complex. A 30-serving bottle costs $35, about $1.17 per day.³

🥉 Third: Midi Daily Cortisol Support. A one-month supply of 60 capsules costs $49.99, about $1.67 per day.⁵

Fourth: Alori Cortisol. A 60-capsule bottle with 30 two-capsule servings costs $69.99, about $2.33 per day. You're paying a premium for the only formula here with every dose on the label and a key ingredient that matches a cortisol study.²,¹²

Conclusion: Alori Is Our Clear Winner

After comparing all four supplements, we found one winner on the two things that matter most in a cortisol supplement: what's in it and the research behind it. And that's Alori Cortisol.

Every ingredient is listed with its exact amount, and its 200 mg of tongkat ali is consistent with a study that found 16% lower cortisol than a placebo. It's also vegan and easy to take, with just two capsules each morning.

Ready to try Alori?

References

1. How chronic stress puts your health at risk, Mayo Clinic
2. Alori Cortisol, Who?
3. Pink Stork Cortisol Complex
4. Integrative Therapeutics Cortisol Manager
5. Midi Daily Cortisol Support
6. Tongkat ali study on stress hormones in moderately stressed adults (2013)
7. Rhodiola research overview, National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health
8. Integrative Therapeutics quality and testing
9. Review of ashwagandha and cortisol in stressed adults (2023)
10. KSM-66 ashwagandha study on stress and anxiety in adults (2012)
11. KSM-66 named as the extract in the 2012 stress study, NutraIngredients
12. Alori Cortisol, Who? serving size at Nordstrom
13. Integrative Therapeutics Cortisol Manager at Vitacost

‍